Father of five avoids jail term for goat theft

ST CATHERINE, Jamaica – A 32-year-old father of five narrowly avoided jail after being convicted of goat theft, but was instead given a two-year suspended sentence.

The decision came after a persuasive hour-long argument from lawyer Rodain Richardson on behalf of his client Anthony Spence.

Spence’s case arose from an incident on May 6, 2024 when a team of police officers, patrolling the main path of Planters on the way to the Old Port, signaled a gray car to stop at about 1:30 am. However, the vehicle took off in an attempt to evade police. After a short chase, the car reportedly crashed on the main road of Lennon’s Ville.

During the search of the vehicle, police found six stolen goats. Spence and another individual were subsequently arrested.

In court, Richardson painted a vivid picture of Spence’s life, marked by brutal struggle, a fatherless childhood and a mountain of responsibilities at a young age. He said Spence, who left school in 9th grade, was the main breadwinner for his three biological children, two stepchildren, his wife and mother. His attorney emphasized that the severe financial burdens Spence faced fueled his continued efforts to make ends meet through various low-paying jobs, including delivery services and carpentry. He further argued that Spence’s actions were driven by sheer desperation rather than criminal intent. The defense also noted Spence’s remorse and his continued efforts to participate in education and rehabilitation programs.

In her sentencing, the parish court judge balanced the seriousness of Spence’s crime with the potential for his rehabilitation and the impact of incarceration on his family members. She sentenced Spence to two years in prison, two years of which were suspended, on condition of good behavior. This means Spence will avoid jail time if he does not offend again within the next two years. In addition, he must comply with the probation department’s supervision and participate in counseling sessions aimed at addressing the underlying issues contributing to his criminal behavior.

Richardson expressed gratitude for the court’s leniency and emphasized that the decision gives Spence a crucial opportunity to turn his life around and better care for his family.

-Jason Cross